Areas · Chestnut Hill

Replacing a Roof on an Older Chestnut Hill House?

Nearly half the homes in 19118 were built before 1940, many under slate. Here is what a new roof involves here.

  • Zip 19118
  • Philadelphia permit and historic rules
  • Free inspection

Is Chestnut Hill a historic district for roofing purposes?

Not as a whole. Chestnut Hill is not on the Philadelphia Historical Commission's list of locally designated districts, but individual buildings anywhere in the city can be designated, without the owner's consent. A designated house needs Commission approval before a roofing permit; an undesignated one needs only the permit.

Housing age in this area

  • 46.7%of homes in 19118 built 1939 or earlier (±3.7 pts)

U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table B25034. Full table: pre-1940 homes by zip.

What are older Chestnut Hill stone and slate houses like?

Many older Chestnut Hill houses are stone, with steep slopes, dormers and chimneys, and a slate roof or a later asphalt layer over one. Nearly half the homes in zip 19118 were built in 1939 or earlier. Replacing that roof usually means a full tear-off, deck repairs, and new flashing where the roof meets the stone.

Most of the neighborhood is in the Chestnut Hill Historic District, listed on the National Register of Historic Places on June 20, 1985 (NRIS 85001334), roughly bounded by Fairmount Park and the Montgomery County line (National Park Service, National Register Information System). That federal listing is not the same as local designation by the Philadelphia Historical Commission. Chestnut Hill as a whole is not on the Commission's list of locally designated districts, so a National Register address does not, by itself, add a Commission review before the roofing permit. Individual buildings can still be designated, so check your address. See historic approvals and replacing a slate roof with asphalt.

What does a slate-to-asphalt job involve on a Chestnut Hill stone house?

It involves a full tear-off of the slate, repair of the board deck underneath, new flashing at stone chimneys and walls, and a slate-toned architectural shingle. Stone houses often have steep slopes and dormers, which add flashing work, so we price each slope after the free inspection rather than by the square.

Philadelphia's published fee for a residential one- or two-family roof covering replacement is $69, effective October 1, 2026, and the EZ Re-Roofing standard requires a full tear-off when the old roof is slate. Permit fees are the municipalities' published figures. They are not a quote for roof work; your price comes after a free inspection.

Chestnut Hill questions

Do the census figures for 19118 include Wyndmoor?
Partly. The census zip code area for 19118 crosses the city line into part of Wyndmoor, so the figure above describes both. We serve the Chestnut Hill side.
Do I need historic approval to replace a roof in Chestnut Hill?
Only if the house itself is locally designated by the Philadelphia Historical Commission. Chestnut Hill as a whole is not a locally designated district, and the neighborhood's 1985 National Register listing does not, by itself, add a Commission review. A designated house needs Commission approval before the roofing permit; an undesignated one needs only the city permit. Check your address, because individual buildings can be designated without the owner's consent.
Can I replace a slate roof with asphalt in Chestnut Hill?
Usually yes, on a house that is not locally designated. Philadelphia's EZ Re-Roofing standard requires a full tear-off when the old roof is slate, then deck repairs, new flashing and asphalt shingles. If the house is locally designated, the Historical Commission has to approve the change first, and staff can approve a close visual match in many cases. Our page on replacing a slate roof with asphalt covers the details, and a free inspection is how we price your house.
What is different about replacing a roof on a Chestnut Hill stone house?
The stone is what usually adds the work. Steep slopes, dormers and chimneys mean more flashing where the new roof meets masonry, and the old board deck often needs repairs once the slate or old shingles come off. We price each slope after a free inspection rather than by the square. Darker charcoal or weathered-slate shingle colors are usually the closest visual match on a stone house coming off slate.

Sources and checked date

Last checked 2026-10-29.

Rules change. Confirm with the city, township or borough permit office before you rely on any permit or historic-district detail here.

Roof trouble in Chestnut Hill?

Tell us where the house is, how old the roof is and what it is doing. If you have photos, say so and we will ask for them by email. Outside our core area? Send the form and ask.

We answer form requests Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. There is no phone line, so the whole conversation stays in writing.

By sending this form you agree to be contacted about your project by email or at the number you give us. Our privacy policy explains how your details are used.

Get a free estimate